Amy is upset after discovering Levi went on a date with Felicity, but Ned tries to calm her down. Meanwhile, Roxy and Kyle overhear Sheilas account of the date and speculate that Felicity might be into polyamory. Sheila finds Levi in the garden and is dismayed to learn that Amy saw them together. Levi refuses to console her, and Amy agrees to mind her own business.

David and Aaron are frustrated with Nicolette for not giving them full custody of Isla, so they consider bringing in lawyers. Nicolette interrupts and takes Isla out for a walk, and later seeks refuge with Jane. Paul offers to get them lawyers, but Aaron believes they should work out a solution with Nicolette.