Kyle is struggling to keep his surgery a secret from his loved ones, while Paul searches for his missing brother. Sheilas advice leads to a comedic twist, and Tereses emotional struggle hints at deeper issues. Lucy emphasizes the importance of honesty, and Mackenzie, Hendrix, and Toadie return home for a sundae. Kyle comes up with a plan to keep Sheila off his back.

Ned confesses to Amy that he teamed up with Felicity to make her jealous, admitting his behavior was partly selfish. Amy is torn by his admission, and they discuss the importance of honesty in their relationship. Meanwhile, Felicity receives a text from Ned that changes her plans with Levi.