After Darryl gets Chyna a bag from the evidence locker at the police station, she pretends to appreciate the thought of the gift, but when Fletcher tells Chyna and Olive about "Pudding Points", a contest with a prize for eating enough pudding, she tries to eat as much as possible to win a new designer bag. Darryl finds the new bag inside the bag he gave her and accuses her of shoplifting. He sends a police officer, Officer 3–9, undercover as a student named Charlie Brown to spy on her. When Chyna, Fletcher, and Olive find out that Charlie Brown is a cop, they pretend that they are robbing a house with Charlie as an accomplice.

Principal Skidmore gives out Wacky Awards and everyone receives one except for Cameron, so Chyna and Olive try to help him find his talent. They make him believe that he is a psychic by making everything he predicts happen. Meanwhile, Fletcher finds out that the dinosaur nuggets at the cafeteria have been replaced; he goes to the board meeting to get them back.In the end Cameron finally knows his not psychic after he predicts the end of the world and it does not happen.