Rick and Amanda Tucker wind up as targets of the killer they are trailing when Amanda's witchcraft turns out to be highly unreliable. Trying to find the so called "elevator" killer in a series of slayings in high-rise buildings, the Tuckers find a clue that sends them to a slick videotape dating service.

A milkman winds up shot dead by a neighbor of Amanda and Rick. Intrigued by the event, the Tuckers investigate only to find the corpse has vanished from the morgue.