24-year-old Meredith Emerson disappears on New Year's Day on a hike up Blood Mountain. Eyewitness accounts of a strange toothless man with a dog lead investigators to Meredith's remains, and uncover several unsolved murders.

A Catholic priest was found with his throat slit in his church of 32 years. Did Father Kunz's investigation of sex abuse in the church play a role in his unsolved murder?