The residents of Berryville, Va., wonder who is to blame for the death of a city official, and as the authorities investigate the murder, they discover that not everyone held the victim in high regard, meaning there were possible murder motives.

Historical Bucks County, Pennsylvania, is alarmed when several young men vanish one after the other within a week. With the support of residents, detectives unearth a ruthless murder spree in this seemingly picture-perfect farming community.