In the 1990s, Spring Valley's Haitian community is rocked when a well-respected civic leader is murdered. It takes police nearly two decades to sift through the rumors and solve a mystery filled with lies and dark secrets.

When one of Redlands, California newest residents goes missing, the distraught community bands together to help find her. But when the case shifts from missing to murder, everyone learns their tranquil little town has a much darker side.