Sully continues to try and figure out his financial worries as he is forced to confront his past; Frank and Edna continue to be at odds over Frank's refusal to make peace with his cousin; Phoebe struggles with her regrets; Maggie plans a family fishing trip hoping to bring Phoebe, Sully, and Andrew closer together, but Andrew's behaviour only causes Maggie to rethink her feelings for him. Meanwhile, Cal entertains a mysterious woman at his cabin while both Rob and Connie deal with relationships of their own.

Maggie enlists Cal's help after Sully decides he must take drastic measures to set things right with Lola. Sydney returns from New York hoping to reconnect with a still heartbroken Rafe. Frank and Edna try to make amends. Sully makes a judgement call that will cost him dearly.