Erin and Aaron decide to have a sing-off to see which one of them gets to keep their first name. When Aaron loses, Erin pushes him to adopt a new country persona to match his middle name. He soon over-commits and Erin needs to help him remember who he is.

After Aaron urges Erin to bond with Sylvia, Erin and Sylvia start spending lots of time together making Aaron and Chuck feel left out. Natasha tries to gain power at her school by having Vivian and Hunter impersonate Erin & Aaron.