James, another former classmate, finds himself next on Molly's "hit list" when he receives an e-mail promising a grim escape from "reality". Struggling to care for his ailing mother, he's hesitant to engage, though Sam and Ethan's call to action may prove irresistible. Later, the discovery of a key figure from Molly's past could shed light on her disappearance, if only they can find him.

Amy, a dangerous woman with ties to Molly, demands answers the friends don't have, leading to an uneasy truce. The significance of Molly's disappearance takes on global implications. On the Dark Web, two lost souls find each other on an exclusive dating forum, but their first date could have grisly consequences.