On a September night in 2005, high school athlete Jennifer Teague vanishes on her late night walk home from work. Her body is found in a swamp 10 days later.

In May 2015, a burnt-out car is found in a parking garage on the outskirts of an Edmonton. Investigators struggle to find who would want to kill mild-mannered, fun-loving, life-of-the-party Dwayne Demkiw.