After Grace's death, Elise gets to bond more with her dad, Henry, as she helps him prepare a surprise for her parents' anniversary. However, their plans go awry when she discovers a dirty little secret about her mother, Claire. Meanwhile, Jarred encounters a freak accident.

As his conscience tortures him, Henry finds refuge in Elise. Meanwhile, Claire and Elise's relationship worsens as the suspicious mother tries to prove that her daughter is not who she claims she is.