The reunion kicks off with Jen revealing the issues that still haunt her and her husband Sharrieff, while Whitney addresses the rumors swirling in her marriage. Meredith confronts Jen about the awkward night at her house, leading to a heated conversation about Brooks. Tensions rise with Lisa and Mary when Lisa defends her friendship with Jen.

The husbands take the stage and Justin reveals shocking details about leaving the Mormon church, Robert addresses Jen and her husband, Sharrieff, and Whitney shares an update on her dad's sobriety. Emotions come to a head when Jen opens up about cultural insensitivities within the group, leaving the women startled and confused with Jen even more hurt than before.