The campers participate in a 3 part canoe race to Boney Island, the Deadliest Place in Muskoka and home to an ancient pet cemetery / ritualistic sacrificial ground / blah blah really scary place, dude. Beth does her team in when she brings home a Tiki doll as a souvenir from Boney Island. Will this bad luck omen wear off on the Screaming Gophers? Or will it last, say the next TWO episodes until they figure out what she's done?

The two teams must make a 3 course meal. The Killer Bass, lead by Geoff, prepare an awesome meal and everything runs smoothly. The love you/hate you thing heats up between Duncan and Courtney, and Geoff and Beth grow closer. Meanwhile, relations on the Gopher team get worse. The team locks Heather in the walk-in fridge, then makes the grave tactical error of leaving Owen in charge of guarding the dinner they've prepared.