Amanda and Mitch lead the investigation into the menacing mail the dean at Jamestown University is receiving. Veronica moves from her parent's home so Preston and Noah help her but her new lodgings are on the scary side.

Preston's friend Noah wants the perfect birthday gift for his dad, a sports fanatic. Noah buys a signed Marino jersey from dealer Mr. Ellison. Amanda and Mitch are currently investigating Ellison for defrauding collectors.