Casey and Alicia must build the case against an uncooperative suspect and try to locate the one witness who can confirm the story of a young woman who was abducted and raped at gunpoint 23 years ago.

A young woman accuses two acquaintances of sexually assaulting her in the back room of a Salt Lake City hookah lounge, but a family tragedy stops her from pressing charges. Three years later, she bravely comes forward to seek justice.