Samantha and Darrin are under close supervision by Hepzibah. Hepzibah then meets a client of Darrin's named Ernest Hitchcock and, thanks to Samantha, Hitchcock falls for the Priestess.

While Darrin sits in jail, Samantha finds out that the bedwarmer is actually a warlock trapped by a witch's spell. Sure enough, the culprit is Serena. Samantha sends Serena back in time to undo the spell used to transform the warlock in the first place. With one situation out of the way, Samantha faces another one, getting Darrin cleared of a crime he did not commit.