When a beloved rabbi's wife turns up dead in one of New Jersey's most idyllic and desirable suburbs, the community is sent into a tailspin. After months of fruitless investigation, police begin to discover that one of Cherry Hill's most powerful couples might not have been as perfect as they seemed.

After a night of glitz and gambling in Atlantic City, a prominent New Jersey couple is attacked on their way home. But what looks like a run of the mill carjacking gone wrong, turns out to be a multipronged conspiracy exposing that suburbia's perfect couple might have been anything but.