Timmy is being made fun of by Dr. Bender and his son Wendell because of his large buck teeth, so he wishes for everyone to look the same. Everyone then turns into gray, unrecognizable blobs. Since the fairies cannot find their godchildren, they began exploding and turning into dust. When Cosmo and Wanda go out to look for Timmy, they have no luck, and Cosmo turns to dust. Wanda is about to as well, but she finds Timmy, who wishes for everyone to turn back to normal, but even after granting that wish, Wanda still turns into dust.