Before his upcoming music video "My Shiny Teeth and Me", evil dentist Dr. Bender rips out Chip Skylark's teeth, stopping him from singing. Timmy must now contact the Tooth Fairy to seek aid in recovering Chip's teeth, and succeeds.

Cosmo has a chance to gain popularity when he is the next on the Fairy World List to host a Fairy Convention, but the convention turns out to be a destination alert when it happens in Timmy's bathroom while Crocker pays a visit.