While the Turners are on their way to Canada, a look-alike duo of bandits called the Turnbaums switch places with Timmy's parents in order to avoid getting punished, and Timmy is simply unable to wish his parents free, because even if magic is used, it could take years to get them out of jail under the US Legal System. It is up to Timmy to get the bandits captured and his parents freed.

Timmy's dad forces Timmy to go with him to check up on his mom, who is caring for her sick aunt, but is really at a snow resort with AJ's, Sanjay's, and Elmer's mothers that she did not want them to go to (because according to Dad, women mean the opposite of what they say, like if they say they do not want to do something, they really do). Vicky goes along with them and is able to take advantage of his view on women (by saying she does not want to do it, his dad thinks she does). While snowboarding, Timmy and Vicky are trapped in a cave after an avalanche, and Timmy cannot wish himself out because Cosmo and Wanda are frozen. Timmy must battle an Abominable Snowman with the help of Vicky.