After his Uncle Albert mails him a mysterious lava lamp, Mr. Crockeraccidentally rubs it and unleashes Norm the Genie. Learning that he can have many wishes as long as he wishes for more, Crocker sets out on several elaborate schemes in an attempt to expose Timmy's fairies, although Norm's trickster nature might make things a little more frustrating for Denzel than he expects.

Timmy battles Remy Buxaplenty in a scavenger hunt, which was actually Cupid's grocery shopping.