Mr. Turner is very busy working; so busy, in fact, that whenever he and Timmy are doing something fun, Mr. Turner will be called off, abandoning his son. To fix this, Timmy finds a solution, to wish up many Dads, so that every time one of them has to leave he will have a replacement. However, when the Dads keep leaving, soon there are too many Dads that all want Timmy for themselves, leaving Timmy to have to remove them.

Cosmo and Wanda are too busy taking care of Poof to tend to an overly adventurous Timmy, so he wishes up a "temporary fairy". Timmy's temporary fairy--Jorgen--is more than happy to fulfill Timmy's wishes, especially the more dangerous ones.