When Poof watches too much of the violent classic "cat and mouse" cartoon, "Cheesy and Sleazy", he turns Timmy and Vicky into the characters from the show, and Timmy must find a way to get back to normal.

Timmy looks forward to his birthday until Jorgen reminds him that each birthday draws him a year closer to losing his fairies; however, Timmy is not worried because his parents always forget his birthday, but he then panics when they seem to remember it this year.