When Bella fosters a group of adorable, snuggly kittens, Polly proves to be quite the "cat-whisperer" with all except one – Custard, a seemingly shy kitten who Polly can't quite seem to crack.

Polly concentrates on the superficial elements, like redo-ing Blossom's cage, instead of on the care materials that Pierce left for her, she ends up losing Blossom! Polly tries to distract Pierce with a day of fun.