Police in Kirtland, Ohio receive a tip about a family of five killed and buried in a barn belonging to a local cult. As they question the cult, investigators learn even more sinister details of power and manipulation leading up to the murders.

After crossing the Mexican Border from Brownsville, Texas, a student out on spring break goes missing. The investigation leads US officials to a cult known for practicing witchcraft led by a former male model and a high school cheerleader.