A few months after Maggie leaves, Max has let himself completely go as a shut in. The Divine appears in his apartment to pluck him out of his depression by bringing him on his on Christmas Carol journey. They visit the past to see how Maggie has always been there protecting him, then whisk away to the present to see her protecting him still even though they've had a big fight. Bringing him to the future reveals that if he doesn't reach out to his support system and resolve things with Maggie, he will remain pregnant and alone. 

Max rushes down the steps of a church to catch up with Patrick, who is on the sidewalk looking at his phone. Max apologizes for not communicating with Patrick for two months, and tries to convince Patrick to talk to him. Patrick explains that he thought Max was with Maggie, and that he has moved on. Max tells Patrick that he is okay with who he is and that he thinks about him all the time. Patrick tells Max that he needs to be with someone who has accepted themselves, and that he doesn't trust Max. Max asks if Patrick is rejecting him because of the pregnancy, and Patrick doesn't answer. Patrick orders Max an Uber and goes back into the church, leaving Max standing on the sidewalk. Max returns home to tell Maggie what happened when Patrick arrives to give him a piece of his mind. Instead Maggie defends Max and Patrick becomes more understanding. Max and The Divine share a tender moment, and as everyone is finding a cheerful mood and unexpected suprise makes the night interesting.