Lisa's article is leaked, criticizing the Gardaí for not acting on Amy's disappearance. David and Detective Brennan chase a lead, Mark Bulger, in Castlemoy. Impatient with the police's pace, Lisa risks her life to uncover what Bulger is hiding.

Lisa has to choose who to save: Susan or Mandy? Chris learns new information that takes Lisa to a strange address, where she discovers incriminating information that someone tries to cover up. The killer calls later that evening for Lisa's decision.