Pursuing a lead that may shed light on his daughter's disappearance, Dave Holloway and a team of investigators dive into a covert operation. The goal: obtain a taped confession, and evidence that could convict his daughter's killer.

TJ and his team head to Aruba to begin phase two of their investigation - attempting to obtain DNA evidence from Natalee's alleged burial site. Dave must convince his informant to go the extra mile to ensure the next step of their investigation.