Having recently split up, Caroline is unsure what to do when Del gives her a gift that she thinks is very expensive. Meanwhile Richard is commissioned to do a nude portrait of a woman who turns out to have ties with the mob.

Caroline's hometown has a ceremony in her honor. Caroline arrives along with Richard to find things haven't changed much, as her brother continues to upstage her at every turn. Annie thinks her understudy is trying to steal her place in Cats.