Sarah's closest rival in the animal show game, Jack McBrayer, takes every opportunity he can to gloat on his success. This time, Jack visits the SPT Offices to show off a very cool jacket he's acquired. Plus, Sarah encounters a classic office problem when she uses the wrong restroom. On stage, Sarah welcomes a variety of stupid and not-so-stupid pet tricks: a dog in search of a world record for a high jump, a horse with a huge talent, a duck artist that can juggle from Brooklyn, and a cat. But which one will win Stupidest Pet Trick of the Week?

Ranger Jim, played by Will Ferrell, stops by to teach Sarah about animal safety. Plus, Sarah meets an incredible dog who has a tale of perseverance to share, a rockstar duck, a rude horse, and some poodle geniuses.