Based on the Redemption series from #1 New York Times Bestselling author Karen Kingsbury, Season One of The Baxters centers on Elizabeth and John's daughter, Kari, who learns the shocking truth that her husband, Tim, has been secretly having an affair. As her relationship is tested, Kari must seek comfort in her faith and family.

Looking for comfort from family and friends, Kari moves back home with her parents. Tim looks to deepen his relationship with Angela. While at home, Kari learns that her first love, Ryan, has moved back to town.