Tucker's girlfriend Vanessa lands an assistant manager position at Ben's bar and makes Ben's life miserable with ridiculous hours and a new uniform. To appease his friend, Ben agrees to try to get along with Vanessa, but when she threatens his job, Ben seizes on an opportunity to get back at her by ruining a big event she's planning. Meanwhile, Danny attempts to set up Riley with a hot new teammate Gerard. Little does he know, Gerard really has eyes for Bonnie.

Ben offers to dog-sit for his girlfriend Megan but the dog doesn't seem to like him much. Tucker has had it with his roommates' messy habits so Danny hires two cute girls to clean the apartment. While the boys are away, the girls rob them, and dognap Lola. Meanwhile, Bonnie convinces Riley to get a home spray tan before her interview to get her job back and ends up botching the tan. In order to prove to her old boss that she's not "too nice" to work for the firm, Riley sues Bonnie.