Riley's thrilled to be invited to a spa day with her boss, but her excitement soon dampens when Bonnie's asked to join the outing as well. Meanwhile, Ben realizes that he used to date Tucker's new girlfriend.

Ben is determined to give Emma the perfect first birthday party, especially since his own was less than stellar. When he decides to host it at the ice cream parlor where he and Riley worked as teenagers, Ben runs into an ex-girlfriend with a mother of a secret. Danny accidentally discovers something about Riley's family that turns her world upside down. Meanwhile, Tucker is in charge of entertainment for the birthday party, a responsibility he takes very seriously.