The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. In the first, a man volunteers to care for his new girlfriend after tummy tuck surgery and then loans her money for rent. His goodwill ends after he alleges that he was hustled into supplying food for her football party. In the next proceeding, a Shih Tzu makes an appearance in court when co-workers fight over a litter of puppies and vet bill costs.

The $10K court max is at stake when a small-town attorney goes up against a small-town mechanic. They dispute liability after a vehicle allegedly implodes during a family road trip.