A puppy makes an appearance in court after suffering a broken paw due to alleged negligence. Roommates fight over who's to blame.

The Judge presides over two cases in this episode. First, a man is sued by a friend for the alleged balance owed on a car; he is questioned about an 'evading the police' text that the Judge discovers. Next up, a software engineer sues a friend over design costs for an array of lights to enhance a keytar; the engineer is countersued for harassment.