In this episode, the Judge rules on two cases. In the first case, after a puppy wanders off and goes missing for months, its owner receives a mysterious letter regarding the dog's alleged whereabouts. In the second case, a woman accuses her roommate of moving her boyfriend in without permission and refuses to return her security deposit.

A man struggles to get his facts straight about the sale of a car when he sues his coworker's wife for payment of the vehicle.