The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. Up first, a man alleges a neighbor's negligence facilitated the theft of his car. He submits footage that not only captures the thieves in action, but exposes a crucial oversight by the neighbor. Next, an Atlanta man sues for a $1,200 Beyoncé ticket, demanding repayment from a former friend who failed to contribute to their New Orleans concert trip.

In part one of this two-part episode, an Indiana woman seeks $9K in damages after she repossesses a car and faces grand theft auto charges when the vehicle is reported stolen.