In part two, ex-fiancées share conflicting narratives of violence, highlighting a chaotic Valentine's Day dispute that ends a week later with a young mother's hospital visit and competing police reports.

The Judge rules on two cases. First, a barbershop owner accuses her former employee of breaching a non-compete agreement by launching a rival shop nearby, a mere three months after leaving her employment. Next, in search of discounted dental work, a couple flies to Colombia for a cosmetic procedure. They break up and proceed to fight over who should pay for the cost of their improved smiles.