The Judge rules on two cases in this episode. Up first, a female artist sues her ex-boyfriend after losing a $4K commissioned painting, alleging his rambunctious kitten destroyed it. In the next case, custody of "Dumpling" the cat, hangs in the balance as ex-lovers fight over ownership and a GoFundMe campaign for the pet's surgery.

Her Honor preside over two cases in this episode. In the first, a woman sues her ex-boyfriend over their shared truck, now solely in his possession. He counters, claiming child support payments eat up half of his paycheck and hinder his ability to pay her back. Next, a family feud erupts over a shared house, with a mother accused of stealing her estranged son's property and harboring his dog.