Andy and both Dr. Abbotts rush to the scene of a disaster at Everwood's coal mine. With the nearest ambulances hours away - and without sufficient supplies - the three must work miracles in the dark.

Love has Everwood in its bewitched-and-bewildered grasp. Andy sends Linda a roomful of roses, Ephram tries reverse psychology on Madison, a stutterer sings his feelings, and Amy is attracted to the town's answer to James Dean.