The atmosphere at the Candlewick Inn darkens when the Sheriff begins conducting searches of everyone's rooms, suspecting one of the wedding party is the killer. New information reveals an eerie connection between Abby and Wakefield, and the tragic events of seven years ago. Malcolm stresses over the possibility that police will find the bag of cash he's concealing and begins to unravel.

Tensions rise after John Wakefield's journal is discovered, and the guests who are still trapped in the Candlewick Inn begin to turn on one another. However, when they uncover a labyrinth of old tunnels beneath the hotel, they are forced to come together to find missing guests. Isolated from the main group, Cal and Chloe attempt to deal with the Sheriff's injuries but find themselves distracted.