After having a bad dream about Leo, Piper realizes that The Powers That Be have ordered Leo to stay away from her forever. As a result, she goes on a strike from helping Prue and Phoebe save innocents. Meanwhile, Phoebe and Prue try to save a young girl named Kate after trolls start attacking her because she's keeping a fairy safe that they want to harm. Cole continues his quest to get inside the Manor and gain access to the Book of Shadows.

After the manor gets burglarized, Piper and Phoebe become concerned that Prue is becoming obsessed with learning everything about the Evil Triad sending demons to destroy them. When Darryl comes to investigate the break-in, he tries to convince Prue that it was the work of human thieves, but she's certain that the suspect is supernatural. Upon meeting with the Triad, Cole is upset that his bosses are sending another demon to try and destroy the Charmed Ones, despite his assurance he'll destroy them on his own. Meanwhile, Piper is certain that Leo's bosses are behind another ruined attempt of having a normal, romantic date.