When Phoebe has a premonition about a demon attacking a young man named Tom, Prue is surprised to find that the intended victim is an old boyfriend of hers. The sisters soon discover that the demon is posing as a sports agent and that Tom is his latest recruit for his demon academy, where the recruits shed the last of their humanity and become demons. Not wanting to lose Tom, Prue agrees that she and her sisters will fight in an underworld wrestling ring to save his soul. Meanwhile, Phoebe tries to find the best way to tell her sisters about Cole.

After visiting a deserted old ghost town with her father, Phoebe begins to have visions of an American-Indian getting beaten up by a local thug and soon starts receiving the same injuries as the man. When Prue and Piper realize that Phoebe is caught up in a time loop of that town, Prue has to go there and with the help of Cole, save Phoebe and the man before the thug kills them and break the loop.