When Cole attempts to unite the underworld before his coronation as the Source, a group of exiled vampires take it upon themselves to kidnap Paige, in an attempt to turn her and as a result, her sisters, vampires so they can claim the evil underworld throne as their own with the help of the Charmed Ones. However, when Cole learns of their plans, he orders that all vampires be killed, and as a result, Paige's life hangs in the balance.

Irritated over the fact that Cole has been ignoring her now that he's the Source, Phoebe destroys several of his demons over the course of a couple days. It is at this time when she has a premonition about an innocent that will soon perish at the hands of a demon, and as a result, she goes to the manor to warn Piper and Paige. When Cole discovers what she has done, Phoebe has to choose which side she has to fight for: good or evil.