Irritated over the fact that Cole has been ignoring her now that he's the Source, Phoebe destroys several of his demons over the course of a couple days. It is at this time when she has a premonition about an innocent that will soon perish at the hands of a demon, and as a result, she goes to the manor to warn Piper and Paige. When Cole discovers what she has done, Phoebe has to choose which side she has to fight for: good or evil.

Following the defeat of the Source, Piper, Phoebe, and Paige are visited by the Angel of Destiny with a tempting reward: continue their lives as the Charmed Ones or relinquish their powers and live normal lives. Their decision however, is put on hold when the sisters discover that they're being investigated by the FBI because of their involvement with a large number of unsolved cases. Meanwhile, Cole is trying to reach out to Phoebe. Later, after the sisters make their decision, Piper and Leo get some miraculous news.