A pair of demons seek revenge on trio of wood nymphs, and as a result, kill their Satyr. Unable to agree on how to proceed with their revenge, one demon tricks the nymphs into thinking he is their new leader, and the other kills one of the nymphs. As the remaining nymphs flee, they decide Paige will be a suitable replacement and turn her into one of them, resulting in Piper and Phoebe trying to find a way to save the nymphs and turn Paige back to normal.

When Grams comes to the manor for a Wiccan birthing ceremony, for Wyatt, the sisters find out that she has brought a memory from her past, a former lover who wants to kill the Charmed Ones and bring back the love they once shared. Meanwhile, Phoebe contemplates Jason's invitation, even though it will take her away from her family, and Paige casts a truth spell to figure out if Nate can accept her being a witch.