After Piper, Phoebe, and Paige have their identities and powers stolen by three evil sisters, they have their work cut out when they have to prove to Chris they're really themselves and to vanquish the fake Charmed Ones.

In order to get Piper, Phoebe, and Paige to concentrate more on their magical duties, Chris conspires with a demon, who, ultimately casts a spell on them where they are sent to an alternate reality where their desires come true. While the sisters are caught in their alternate realities, Leo confronts Chris about the Valkyries and threatens to talk to the other elders about clipping his wings for his killing of one in order to get her pendant. Meanwhile, Leo and Piper disagree over how to care for a sick Wyatt.