It's Phoebe's high school reunion and Paige plans on tagging along with her to the big party. However, as Paige looks through Phoebe's yearbook, she sees a side of Phoebe she's never seen before and decides to cast a spell to help her through the night and ultimately doesn't turn out as she hoped. Meanwhile at the Manor, Piper calls Victor for help in trying to find out why Chris is being so distant now that she's pregnant.

When the sisters are caught on tape using their magical powers, Darryl faces the brunt of the consequences when he gets implicated in a murder after the Cleaners arrive to take care of the mess. As a result, Piper, Phoebe, and Paige go on trial where there is a distinct possibility where they are stripped of their powers.