After seeing her new boss die by the hands of a demon right in front of her, Paige discovers that he sold his soul to that demon and the demon was just collecting the debt. However, when she tells Piper and Phoebe about what happened, Paige is disappointed when they tell her not to go after the demon to save him, and as a result, ignores their advice and makes a huge sacrifice in order to save her boss.

After the sisters kill a Manticore, they soon discover that it was a mother when they find its baby. As a result, they soon find themselves taking the baby in and promptly begin to wonder if they could raise the half demon child to be a force for good instead of evil. Meanwhile, Piper, Phoebe, Paige, and Leo have to find a way to help Darryl after he obtains magical powers.